I have just finished Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy by John le Carré. Tonight, I am watching the movie, exciting times!
In the end, I enjoyed the book, even though it felt like a bit of a slog initially; trying to navigate a dense plot and ensemble cast of characters with no idea which snippets of information might end up being crucial. I’m also rubbish at remembering character’s names– at one point, I even considered making a chart.
The novel is low-key in tone and full of antiheroes, nakedly flawed–miserable about their love lives, failures and friendships even as they heroically serve their nation. Le Carre does nothing to glamorise espionage but what he does achieve is so much greater; a glimpse into its mundanity, futility and humanity. When the mole is finally outed, there is a pervading mood of anti-climax and distaste — a trusted and liked colleague proved as a liar and the fickleness of our ideological systems and loyalties pointedly exposed:
“[The mole] was more than his model, he was his inspiration, the torch bearer of a certain kind of antiquated romanticism, a notion of English calling which– for the very reason that it was vague and understated and elusive–had made sense of Guillam’s life till now. In that moment, Guillam felt not merely betrayed but orphaned. “












Hannah Stoney is a British artist and writer.
I loved the book, but ultimately the film seemed like a rather flawed concept – it was very good for what it was, but in order to squeeze the story into the format they had to remove all the “slog”. As a result there didn’t seem to be time to develop any interest in who the mole actually was. Having said that it was great visually. But overall I preferred the Alec Guinness TV version.
Btw, I’d definitely recommend The Spy Who Came In From The Cold if you haven’t read that.
Yes, that’s a very good critique. I don’t think I would have enjoyed the film nearly so much if I hadn’t just finished the book.
I would love to see the BBC version sometime but I can’t find it on YouTube. My dad keeps telling me how good it is too.